You're probably paying too much for Google Ads. Here's how to check.
A disclosed Google Ads management fee is normal. A hidden markup is not. Five questions to find out what you're actually paying.
- Google Ads
- Advertising
- Pricing
A few years ago, I was handed a monthly ads report at a regional healthcare system in Kansas. It had the agency’s logo on every page, a list of keywords, a click count, and an impression count. It looked professional. It told us almost nothing.
When I set up a test campaign myself for the same local market, clicks cost about $2. Through the agency, we were effectively paying $14 to $15 per click. Same Google, same town, roughly seven times the price.
We brought the ads in-house. Annual ad spend went from $84,000 to $18,000.
I thought that was a one-off. Then I saw the same pattern at the multi-state nonprofit where I work now: an agency, a flat monthly bill, a polished report, and an effective cost around five times what the ads actually cost. When we brought that in-house too, the same budget suddenly went a lot further. When each click costs a fraction of what it used to, you can reach more people in more places for the same money.
How this happens
Most agencies charge a management fee, and that’s fair. Managing ads well takes real work. The problem is when the fee isn’t disclosed as a fee. Some agencies bill you a single “ad spend” number, pay Google a smaller amount, and keep the difference. If you never see Google’s side of the ledger, you have no way to know.
The reports make it worse. Clicks and impressions are easy to show and hard to argue with. What’s usually missing is what those clicks did once they landed on your website.
Five questions to ask about your ads
1. Do I own the Google Ads account? It should be under your organization’s login, with the agency added as a manager. If they own it, you lose your history when you leave.
2. Can I log in right now? Not a dashboard they built for you. The actual account.
3. Does Google bill me directly? If your card or invoice is with Google, you see real spend. If the agency bills you for ads, ask for Google’s invoices.
4. What’s my actual cost per click? Compare the number in the Google Ads account to your total bill divided by clicks. If those are far apart, you’ve found your markup.
5. What happened after the click? Form submissions, calls, donations, appointments. If your report stops at clicks, nobody knows whether the ads work.
What fair looks like
A disclosed management fee is normal. Most pricing guides put it somewhere between 10% and 20% of ad spend, often with a monthly minimum. At 20%, a dollar of ads costs you $1.20. What I ran into cost $5 to $7.
When I manage ads for an organization, I work in their account, they’re billed by Google directly, and my fee is a separate, stated number that goes down as the budget goes up. They get the raw data, not a branded summary. And because I usually manage the website too, I can follow a visitor from the ad to the page to the form, which is the part most reports leave out.
If you’re not sure what you’re paying, send me a note and I’ll help you find out. Bring your last invoice.